Rye Whiskey 2019
 

Best Rye Whiskey 2019

 

The Fifty Best Rye Whiskey Tasting 2019


The Tasting:
The Fifty Best held a “blind” tasting of 23 American rye whiskies with a panel of 18 judges. Strict tasting rules were applied. The order of service was established beforehand by lottery. The ryes were poured into fresh glasses from new sealed bottles, and served at room temperature. Each of the ryes were judged and scored separately. Only ice water, unflavored unsalted crackers and chips were available to cleanse the palate.

The judges wrote down their impressions of each product on score sheets. The scoring was done on a 5-point system, with 5 as the highest. Double-Gold, Gold and Silver medals were awarded according to a set range of final point scores received from the judges. Overall, the scores were exceptionally high for this tasting. There were no Bronze medals awarded. The tasting notes below are summaries of the judges’ opinions, with all replicated commentary eliminated. The distilleries, states of origin, alcohol proof and other tidbits are identified for each brand. Following the tasting results is a brief history of rye whiskey.



DOUBLE GOLD MEDAL WINNERS

Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey
(Buffalo Trace Distillery, KY) 90° prf

Nose: Caramel, nougat, cocoa, brittle, kettle corn, vanilla, cream, maple, honey, jam, candied apple, cherry, dried cherry, grilled figs, figs, apple, green apple, castile soap, toast, nut, cinnamon, spice, tree leaves, pine wood, oak.
Palate: Dark cocoa, nougat, buttery, creamy, brown sugar, honey, prunes, cooked cherries, cherry, coconut, apriums, strawberry, ripe fruit, green apple, mint, herbs, sugar-roasted nuts, toasted nuts, rye, wheat, toast, nutmeg, clove, orange spice, sweet spice, warm spice, spicy, pink peppercorns, black pepper, woody, oak, balanced, well-rounded, smooth.
Finish: Dark chocolate, mandarin, orange, dried cherry, grain, minty, cinnamon, spice, spicy, white pepper, peppery, balanced, complex, Sazerac cocktail preferred, nice, creamy, smooth, mild, warming, beautiful.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey



Old Potrero Straight Rye Whiskey
(Hotaling & Co., CA)
100% rye. Aged a minimum 4-1/2 years. 97° prf

Nose: Caramel, nougat, dark chocolate, cream, vanilla, honey, apricot, cherry, ripe plums, ripe bananas, dried apricot, plantains, toast, dry cocoa, coffee, black walnuts, sandalwood, wormwood, nutmeg, spice, musty, dark spiced rum, complex, fragrant.
Palate: Caramel, toffee, cherry, boysenberry, very ripe banana, quince, green apple, fig, cinnamon syrup, buckwheat, toast, nutty, clove, allspice, nutmeg, tarragon, jalapeño, sweet oak, heavy, rich, bold, complex.
Finish: Chocolate-covered cherry, cacao, vanilla, demerara syrup, honey, coffee, tobacco, oak, smooth, balanced, tasty, rich, elegant.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Old Potrero Straight Rye Whiskey



Wigle Single Barrel Straight Rye Whiskey
(Pittsburgh Distilling Co., PA)
Aged 4 years. 100° prf

Nose: Toffee, dark toffee, buttery, caramel, milk chocolate, vanilla, cherry, black cherry, white cherry, pineapple, herbal, mint, menthol, rye, rye bread, rye flair, grain, nutmeg, black coffee, smoky, rich wood, oak.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, cocoa, dark sugar, cream, whipped cream, vanilla, sweet vanilla, maple, raisins, prunes, cherry, plum, orange peel, fresh bread, toast, rye, rye flour, grain, potato, herbal, peppermint, cinnamon, peppery, coffee, tobacco, cigar, leather, tannin, smoke, smoky, oak, nicely balanced, scotch-like, rich, smooth, zesty, mouth-watering.
Finish: Caramel, creamy, maple, dried fruit, corn, ginger, anise, walnut, nutmeg, cloves, spicy, touch of pepper, peppery, oak, good heat, super dry, round, nice, smooth, very pleasant.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Wigle Single Barrel Straight Rye Whiskey



John Myer New York Straight Rye Whiskey
(Myer Farm Distillers, NY) 90° prf

Nose: Cocoa, cocoa powder, toasted marshmallow, light brown sugar, honeycomb, honey, cherry, berry, apricot, banana, ginger bread cake, ginger, wheat, grain, flour, sourdough, peppermint, light spice, straw, leather, earthy, new wood, oak, pine, armagnac.
Palate: Toffee, molasses, maple, honey, apricot, banana, dates, figs, dried fruit, orange peel, straw, grain, rye, nut, clove, nutmeg, spice, spicy, burnt toast, tobacco, earth, leather, woody, balanced, smooth, zesty, good rye character, classic.
Finish: Dates, fig jam, orange marmalade, citrus, sourdough, rye, vegetal, nutmeg, spicy, peppery, white pepper, mint, menthol, super dry, creamy, smooth, zesty.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



John Myer New York Straight Rye Whiskey



Old Overholt Bonded Straight Rye Whiskey
(KY)
Bottled-In-Bond. 100° prf

Nose: Toffee, cocoa, nougat, maple syrup, maple, buttery, slight vanilla, honey, honeycomb, plums, cherry, cherry juice, banana, strawberry, buckwheat, toast, almond, almond bark, spice, earthy, cedar, mild oak.
Palate: Caramel, maple, buttery, vanilla, honey, cherry, sweet apple, grain, rye grain, walnut, nut, mixed nuts, licorice, mint, cinnamon, dark baking spice, woodsy, oak, bourbon-like, nicely sweet, creamy, smooth.
Finish: Great toffee, caramel, honey, cherry, sweet corn, rye bread, licorice, cinnamon, nutmeg, spice, spicy, smoky, oak, pine, well rounded, well-balanced, soft, smooth, zesty.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Old Overholt Bonded Straight Rye Whiskey



MuckleyEye Straight Rye Whiskey
(Colts Neck Stillhouse, NJ)
Aged not less than 2 years. 90° prf

Nose: Toffee, brown sugar, light caramel, creamy, vanilla, honey, banana, ripe banana, pineapple, cherry, mixed berries, pear, apple cider, green apple, ginger, rye, grain, toast, wheat field, bamboo, nutmeg, spice, mixed spices, light char.
Palate: Caramel, sugar cane, burnt sugar, cola, honey, fresh dark plums, cherry, strawberry, ripe banana, apple, grapes, dates, dried fruit, herbal, herbaceous, anise, mint, hazelnut, nutty, rye, cinnamon, spice, white pepper, oak, creamy, smooth, fresh, zingy.
Finish: Dried fruit, brown sugar, creamy, walnut, nutty, rye, tobacco, vegetal, mint, spice, pepper, hint of black pepper, woody, oak, crisp, Manhattan cocktail preferred.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



MuckleyEye Straight Rye Whiskey



Cleveland Underground Rye Whiskey
(Cleveland Whiskey, OH)
Finished with black cherry wood. 90° prf

Nose: Caramel, toffee, dark chocolate, buttery, vanilla, honey, marmalade, cherry, apricot, dried apple, green apple, green apple skins, lemongrass, mint, chamomile, herbal, rye, clove, black pepper, leather, cedar.
Palate: Caramel, buttery, honey, apricot, strawberry, fig, orange zest, dried apple, sour green apple, minty, clove, hint of cinnamon, baking spice, great warm spice, spicy, peppery, wood, pinewood, cedar, oaky, charred barrel, beautiful dryness, zingy texture, creamy, smooth.
Finish: Cherry, plum, soft fig, clover honey, vanilla, grain, mint, nutmeg, cinnamon, ginger spice, white pepper, light spice, creamy, soft, smooth, cozy, approachable, elegant, great.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Cleveland Underground Rye Whiskey



Booker's Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
(James B. Beam Distilling Co., KY)
Aged 13 years. 136.2° prf

Nose: Caramel, heavy caramel, toffee, milk chocolate, cocoa, strong maple, brown sugar, vanilla, honey, cherry, ripe cherries, macerated fruit, marmalade, apricot, floral, herbal, rye, olive brine, tobacco, oak, cedar, interesting, big, beautiful.
Palate: Dark chocolate, cherries, dark cherry, honey, rye, grain, cereal, sweet straw, walnuts, toasted nuts, sweet nuttiness, clove, huge zingy spice, spicy, salty, sea salt, maritime, smooth, rich, cognac, unique, delicious.
Finish: Toffee, mocha, toasted honey, green apple, grain, nutmeg, spicy, peppery, briny, leather, smoky, woody, complex, zesty, awesome.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Booker's Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey



Knob Creek Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
(Knob Creek Distilling Co., KY)
100° prf

Nose: Toffee, butterscotch, creamy, buttery, dark chocolate, vanilla, honey, cherry, pineapple, ginger, light rye, bread dough, vegetal, straw, myrtle leaves, nutty, spice, leather, bamboo, sharp wood, forest.
Palate: Caramel, nougat, creamy, molasses, buttery, vanilla, sweet vanilla, honey, dates, cherry, strawberry, pineapple, toast, cereal, mixed grains, minty, cashews, nutty, cinnamon, spice, black pepper, fireplace, oak, cedar, well-balanced, zingy, velvety, smooth.
Finish: Cherry, sweet cherry, vanilla, maple, honey, toasted bread, mint, menthol, nice spice, spicy, white pepper, oak, bourbon, good balance, round, nice, soft, smooth, well made, great.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal



Knob Creek Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey



GOLD MEDAL WINNERS

Monterey Rye – Batch No. 24
(Fog's End Distillery, CA) 90° prf

Nose: Butterscotch, caramel, sweet caramel, salted caramel, soft toffee, dark sugars, hot chocolate, strong vanilla, vanilla!, creamy eclairs, honey, apricot, plum, berries, banana, ripe banana peel, buttered popcorn, butter, buttered toasted oats, walnut, earth, gentle oak, dry oak.
Palate: Toffee, buttery caramel, cocoa, light chocolate note, vanilla, powdered sugar, dates, plum, ripe banana peels, minty, peppermint, almond, roasted nuts, clove, nutmeg, cinnamon, spicy, peppercorn, rye, leather, oak, nicely balanced, smooth, bold, zesty, delicious.
Finish: Caramel, creamy, green apple, herbal, walnut, hazelnut, spicy, white pepper, peppery, wood, balanced, dry, crisp, silky, tasty, elegant, delightful.

Gold Medal
Gold medal



Monterey Rye Batch No. 24



Sugar House Rye Whiskey
(Sugarhouse Distillery, UT)
80% rye, 10% malted rye. 92° prf

Nose: Caramel, toffee, dark chocolate, vanilla, brown sugar, burnt sugar, raisins, dried apples, hint of strawberry, plum, ginger, mint, black tea, flour, nut, sweet nuttiness, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, pepper, tobacco, wood chips, tree bark, oak, very oaky.
Palate: Toffee, nougat, cocoa, dark brown sugar, butter, creamy, sweet vanilla, honey, cherry, apricot, orange, citrus, green apple, mint, sweet pea, rye, grain, mixed grains, nuttiness, nutmeg, spice, white pepper, tobacco leaves, oak, great balance, smooth.
Finish: Vanilla, creamy, creamed corn, cocoa, semi-sweet raisins, dried fruit, orange zest, herbs, pepper, toast, coffee, leather, oaky, well balanced, approachable, zesty, velvety, silky, smooth, Old Fashioned cocktail.

Gold Medal
Gold medal



Sugar House Rye Whiskey



Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye Whiskey
(Old Fashioned Copper Distillery, Frankfort, KY)
Bottled-In-Bond. Aged at least 4 years. 100° prf

Nose: Toffee, caramel, nougat, brown sugar, butter, vanilla, honey, bananas, bubble gum, orange rind, crystallized ginger rye toast, walnuts, nutty, clove, spice, oak, brandy.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, cocoa, mocha, hot mocha, chocolate, vanilla, dried fruit, cherry, ripe banana, apricot, apples, green apple, orange peel, citron, strong citrus, grain, rye flour, rye, classic rye character, nutty, pepper, spice, spicy, black pepper, oak, zingy, rich, smooth.
Finish: Mocha, crème brûlée, banana pudding, sherry, mint julep, citrus, walnut, nutty, rye, grain, light spice, peppery, clean, zingy, zesty, smooth, approachable.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye Whiskey



No. 4 Westchester Rye Whiskey
(StillTheOne Distillery, NY)
100% New York State rye. Aged 34 months. 90° prf

Nose: Caramel, nougat, brown sugar, sugar cane, powdered sugar, maple syrup, vanilla, honey, pineapple, plum, root vegetables, herb, minty, rye flour, grain, roasted hazelnut, nutty, allspice, thyme, earthy, leather, camp fire, oak, cognac.
Palate: Salted caramel, burnt custard, cream, sugar cane, maple, sweet pastry, butter, bananas foster, apricot, dark cherry, plum, toasty apples, green apple, ginger, herbs, rye, toast, walnuts, roasted nuts, nuts, spice, baking spice, black pepper, charred cedar, oak.
Finish: Maple, grain, toast, grain, mint, clove, cinnamon, spicy, citrus zest, zesty, very flavorful, nice sweetness, bold, rich, memorable.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



No. 4 Westchester Rye Whiskey



Driftless Glen Straight Rye Whiskey – Single Barrel
(Driftless Glen Distillery, WI)
Aged minimum 2 years. 96° prf

Nose: Light toffee, buttered rum, sugar cane, strong vanilla, maple, honey, ripe peaches, plum, strawberry, walnuts, nutty, bread, cinnamon, menthol, spearmint, tobacco, leather, rum-like, bourbon-like.
Palate: Caramel, toffee, sugar cane, creamy, vanilla, sweet cake, dates, plum, cherry, sweet fruit, apple, anise, mint, herb, roasted almonds, rye, strong rye, clove, spice, spicy, leather, woody, oaky, mellow oak, balanced, good sweet note, rich, zesty.
Finish: Caramel, dark chocolate, nougat, buttery, vanilla, raisin, apple, herbs, grain, spicy, peppery, earthy, oak, balanced, zingy, zesty, smooth, approachable.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



Driftless Glen Straight Rye Whiskey Single Barrel



Basil Hayden’s Dark Rye
(Kentucky Springs Distilling Co., KY)
Kentucky straight rye whiskey blended with Canadian rye whisky and port. 80° prf

Nose: Caramel, nougat, vanilla, brown sugar, honey, dried apricot, dried fruit, ripe bananas, banana, rich plum, strawberry, sweet green apple, cola nut, walnuts, toast, anise, clove, very light cinnamon, leather, cedar, oak.
Palate: Toffee, caramel, nougat, buttery, creamy, vanilla cream, sugar cane, heavy sugar, sweet ripe banana, sweet plum, plums, raisins, raw dough, flour, nuts, roasted nuts, rye, spice, spicy, pepper, black pepper, well balanced, smooth, soft approach, very mellow.
Finish: Toffee, creamy, buttery, brown butter, honey, dried prunes, dried fruits, rye flour, walnut, pecan, nutty, cinnamon, nutmeg, oak, lingering sweetness, bourbon-like, rich, bright, lively, beautiful.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



Basil Hayden’s Dark Rye



1420 Hemped Rye Spirit
(Sono 1420 Artisan Distillers, CT)
Distilled from 75% rye, 15% corn & 10% milled hemp seed. 92° prf

Nose: Caramel, vanilla, raisin, prune, dried berries, ripe banana, apricot, cherry, strawberry, green apple, citrus, herbs, eucalyptus, floral, perfume-y, rye flour, grain, spice, light tobacco, oak.
Palate: Caramel, toffee, maple, honey, raisins, dried apricot, dried fruit, cherry, green apples, orange zest, floral, herbs, mint, fresh mint, menthol, anise, nutty, cinnamon, spicy, lots of pepper, green walnuts, coffee, leather, tobacco, light smoke, smoke, well balanced, zesty, smooth, approachable.
Finish: Dark chocolate, creamy, vanilla, honey, dried pears, orange blossom, citrus, peppery, spicy, black pepper, rye flour, oak, light oak, woody, winter season, balanced, complex, soft, smooth, gentle, pleasant, elegant.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



1420 Hemped Rye Spirit



New Holland Beer Barrel Rye
(New Holland Brewing Co., MI) 88° prf
Rested in American oak, finished in Dragon’s Milk beer barrels.

Nose: Caramel, nougat, cocoa, chocolate, butter, sugar cane, molasses, maple, caramel apple, dried apricots, basket of fruits, banana, cherry, strawberry, pear, lemon, green apple skins, rose, sweet herbs, cinnamon, nutmeg, black pepper, leather.
Palate: Toffee, dark sugar, vanilla, honey, apricot candy, apricots, sweet cherries, Rainier cherries, tangy cherry, plum, papaya, herbal, barley, rye, malty, coffee, rosemary, oregano, spicy, black pepper, licorice, mossy, leather, wood, powerful punch, smooth.
Finish: Sweet cherries, cherry note, apricot, dried fruit, herb, amaretto, resin, grain, rye, coffee, spicy, pepper, balanced, zesty.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



New Holland Beer Barrel Rye



Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Whiskey
(Hillrock Estate Distillery, NY)
Aged under 4 years. Master Distiller Dave Pickerell. 90° prf

Nose: Toffee, caramel, nougat, dark sugar, maple syrup, vanilla, sweet vanilla, honey, dried fruit, cherry, wild cherry, plum, pineapple, ginger, grain, rye, wheat flour, nutty, mint, cloves, spice, saline, leather, oak.
Palate: Toffee, chocolate, chocolate nut, sugar cane, maple syrup, dried fruit, dried apricot, dried dates, sweet cherry, cherry, banana, strawberry, oatmeal, wheat, malt, rye, tobacco, fresh fig leaves, tobacco leaf, earthy, herbal, clove, cinnamon, spicy, smoky, leather, oak, sweet at first, rich, smooth.
Finish: Dried cherries, dried fig, creamy, choco/tobacco, tobacco, rye, rye bread, grain, mint, walnuts, black pepper, forest floor, woody, oaky, spicy, lively, zingy, zesty.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Whiskey



Driftless Glen 51 Rye Whiskey
(Driftless Glen Distillery, WI)
Aged more that 2 years. 102° prf

Nose: Dark chocolate, chocolatey, caramel, caramel custard, soft hint of butter, maple, vanilla, honey, cherries, apple peel, ginger, hint of mint, roasted beans, black tea, rye, clove, cinnamon, spicy, leather, camp fire, oak.
Palate: Caramel, demerara, maple, honey, cherries, plum, apricot, citrus, toast, mixed grains, rye, mint, nutty, clove, spice, spicy, pepper, black pepper, leather, very woody, oak, bitter oak, nicely sweet, creamy.
Finish: Vanilla, dates, cherry, dried orange peels, lemon rind, lemon zest, spicy, tobacco, woodsy, wood tannin, oak, cedar, creamy, smooth.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



Driftless Glen 51 Rye Whiskey



Lost Republic Rye Whiskey
(Lost Republic Distilling Co., Healdsburg, CA)
Aged not less than 2 years. 90° prf

Nose: Toffee, butterscotch, nougat, cocoa, chocolate, Milky Way bar, cream, sweet, babka, maple, light burnt sugar, hint of honey, ripe banana, vanilla, cherry, dark cherry, jasmine, toasty, walnut, nutmeg, cinnamon, white peppercorn, leather, earth, fresh cut wood, woody, oak.
Palate: Cherry, banana, banana peel, zesty tangerine, dried fruit, green apple skins, ginger, mint, herbs, dry grass, grain, buttery, graham cracker, toast, spice cake, sweet cinnamon, allspice, spicy, black pepper, perfume, leather, smoky, charred wood, oak, balanced.
Finish: Caramel, apricot, ripe apples, citrus, mint, herbs, spicy, peppery, black pepper, grain, oak, well balanced, nice zing, zingy, zesty.


Gold Medal
Gold medal



Lost Republic Rye Whiskey



SILVER MEDAL WINNERS

Wigle Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey
(Pittsburgh Distilling Co., PA)
Monongahela rye. Certified organic. 84° prf

Nose: Caramel, Charleston Chew, buttery, nougat, cocoa, dark chocolate, vanilla, crème brûlée, cotton candy, honey, cherry, dried cherry, banana, pineapple, dried oats, toasty, flour, wheat flour, grain, matzo, bamboo shoots, hazelnut, sweet nuttiness, roasted nuts, spice, spicy, leather, woodsy, oak, bourbon barrel.
Palate: Caramel, dark chocolate, sugar cane, honey, red cherry, orange, dried fruit, barley, herbs, grainy, nuttiness, clove, nutmeg, spicy, pepper, mint, green leaves, earthy, tobacco, leather, oak, fresh oak, cedar, great mouth feel, bright, tasty, beautifully creamy, smooth, gentle.
Finish: Dark chocolate, mocha, toasted, grain, buttery, leather, orange zest, pepper, herbs & spice, wood spice, softly spicy, balanced, zesty, elegant, great for cocktails.


Silver Medal
Silver medal



Wigle Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey



Rabbit Hole Boxergrail Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
(Rabbit Hole Distillery, KY)
95% rye, 5% malted rye. Aged over 3 years. 95° prf

Nose: Toffee, caramel, butter, vanilla, marzipan, maple, maple syrup, honey, dried figs, apricot, spiced fruit, ginger, sweetened breakfast cereal & milk, corn, rye flour, nut, peanuts, spice, mineral, green leaves, bark, oaky.
Palate: Caramel, sugar cane, honey, clover honey, maple, cherry, apricot, ripe banana, dried fruit, sweet potato, vegetal, veggie, rye, grain, toasted grain, nutty, mint, cinnamon, spice, hot spice, black pepper, leather, oak, full flavor, creamy, smooth.
Finish: Creamy, raisins, pineapple, green apples, ginger, minty, anise, roasted nuts, tarragon, spicy, peppery, white pepper, nice, cozy.


Silver Medal
Silver medal



Rabbit Hole Boxergrail Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey



Yellow Rose Distilling Rye Whiskey
(Yellow Rose Distilling, TX)
Aged at least 1 year. 90° prf

Nose: Brown sugar, honey, ripe plum, cherry, apple, green apple, lemon zest, citrus, green grass, arugula, straw, smooth grain, nutty, nutmeg, hint of clove, cinnamon, spice, pepper, hints of pepper, faint leather, oaky, charred oak, aged barrel.
Palate: Nougat, honey, macerated apple, green apple, citrus, orange zest, ginger, green grass, herbs, straw, grain, walnuts, toasted walnuts, clove, bright nutmeg, spice, pepper, apple jack, soft leather, oak, creamy, buttery, well balanced, smooth.
Finish: Creamy, sugar cane, lemon, anise, nutty, oak, pepper, jalapeno, spicy, zingy, zesty, pleasant, great.


Silver Medal
Silver medal



Yellow Rose Distilling Rye Whiskey

 

 

Disclaimer: This section of the website is intended for visitors 21 years of age and older.
If you are not of legal drinking age, please exit by clicking here.


Please drink responsibly!