Domestic Vodka
 

Best Domestic Vodka

 

The Fifty Best Domestic Vodka Tasting 2024


The Fifty Best held a “blind” tasting of 13 American-made unflavored craft vodkas with eight members of our spirits judging panel. The order of service was established beforehand by lottery. Strict tasting rules were applied. The vodkas were poured into fresh glasses from new sealed bottles, and served at slightly above room temperature. Only ice water, neutral unflavored crackers and chips were available to cleanse the palate.

The judges wrote down their impressions of each product on score sheets. The scoring was done on a 5-point system, with 5 as the highest. Double-Gold, Gold and Silver medals are awarded according to a set range of final point scores received from the judges. No Bronze medals were awarded for this tasting. Medals are provided based entirely on merit and only to products judged worthy of such award.

The tasting notes that follow are summaries of the judges’ opinions, with all replicated commentary eliminated. The distilleries, states of origin and other tidbits are identified for each brand. All vodkas are 80° proof, unless otherwise indicated. Clicking on the brands' names will link to their websites.


DOUBLE-GOLD MEDAL WINNERS


Mermaid Vodka
(Dunamis Premium Spirits, FL)
Distilled from corn. Charcoal filtered 10x.

Nose: Vanilla, faint cream, stone fruit, citrus, violet, spearmint, menthol, grassy, wet grain, potato skin, mineral, delicate, clean, crisp, fresh.
Palate: Cream, cane sugar, strawberry, sweet dried apricots, cane sugar, rye, herbal, creamy spice, cracked peppercorn, earth, minerals, creamy mouthfeel.
Finish: Vanilla, lemon peel, white peppercorn, intense crescendo, clean, crisp, smooth, rich.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


   Mermaid Vodka


Dented Brick Distillery Vodka
(UT)
Distilled from 80% pumpernickel rye & 20% red winter wheat.
Limestone filtered artesian well water from Rocky Mountain snow melt.

Nose: Strawberry, berries, mango, honeydew melon, tropical fruit, vanilla, very creamy, cookie dough, marzipan, almond, almond paste, winter mint, wintergreen.
Palate: Dry cocoa, nibs, vanilla, sugar cookie, black cherry, honeydew, marzipan, cashew, licorice, sweetened coffee note, winter mint, tarragon, grassy, mossy, creamy.
Finish: Cherry cola, white sugar, eucalyptus, pepper, black pepper, grainy, mineral, zesty, intense, clean, fresh, delicate, good for sipping.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


Dented Brick Distillery Vodka


Yacht Life Vodka
(Suncoast Loaded Cannon Distilled Spirits, FL)
16x distilled from American wheat. Charcoal filtered.

Nose: Vanilla ice cream, powdered sugar, Fruit Loops cereal, pear, green apple, floral, lemongrass, potato, potato skin, whole grain bread, bread dough, slightly earthy, mineral, bright.
Palate: Vanilla, cream, ripe pear, melon, black cherry, lavender, herbaceous, grassy, mossy, white pepper, earth, dusty, minerals, clean, crisp.
Finish: Pear, rosewater, herbal, mint, slightly peppery, smooth, astringent, zesty, intense.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


Yacht Life Vodka


Mutiny Island Vodka
(Sion Farm Distillery, St. Croix, USVI)
Distilled from breadfruit.

Nose: Pastry dough, soft-serve ice cream, powdered sugar, light mocha, nutmeg, balsam, mineral, cucumber water, spa water, clean, crisp.
Palate: Cream, whipped cream, confectioners’ sugar, lemon cake, lemon zest, mint, cocoa, rye, white pepper, mineral salty, mineral, dusty, smoky, creamy mouthfeel, smooth.
Finish: White pepper, lingering spice, balanced, zesty, assertive, soft, smooth.


Double Gold Medal
Double Gold medal


Mutiny Island Vodka



GOLD MEDAL WINNERS

SINPATCH Vodka
(Tenmile Distillery, NY)
Distilled from local high-quality grain.
Filtered through charcoal made from recycled oak whiskey barrels.

Nose: Caramel, creamy, vanilla, vanilla cake, dessert, ripe banana, kiwi, bubblegum, herbal, wheatgrass, cereal, bread, dough.
Palate: Caramel, cocoa, powdered sugar, cream, sugar & cream, kiwi, anise, mint, subtle herbal notes, macadamia nut, dough, pepper, smoky, complex, balanced, clean, creamy, delicious.
Finish: Mint, peppery, has an air of fun, vibrant, zesty, creamy, easy drinking.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


SINPATCH Vodka


High Rock Vodka
(Sugarlands Distilling Co., TN)  88° proof
7x distilled from corn. 3x sugar maple charcoal filtered.

Nose: Cocoa powder, grain, floral notes, tarragon, mineral.
Palate: Cocoa, cashews, coffee, citrus peel, black pepper, peppery, spicy, creamy, great for cocktails.
Finish: Vanilla, anise, minty, grassy note, peppery, spicy, tobacco, clean, complex, rich.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


High Rock Vodka


King's Family Distillery Vodka
(TN)
6x distilled from corn.

Nose: Lemon peel, citrus, grassy, hint of grain, bread, snow water, melted snow, soft..
Palate: Vanilla frosting, powdered sugar, melon, herbal, almond oil, celery salt, peppery, dusty, smooth, mellow, gentle on the palate, very approachable, soft, silky.
Finish: Forest floor, saline, smooth, rich, gentle, delicate.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


King's Family Distillery Vodka


Tahoe Blue Vodka
(Tahoe Spirits, NV)
Distilled from a blend of 3 vodkas (50% sugarcane,
25% grape, 25% corn). Made with Tahoe water.

Nose: Lemon peel, Juicy Fruit gum, pastry dough, very faint scent of cocoa, anise, woodruff, mineral, crisp, subtle.
Palate: Cream, orange cream, orange peel, Juicy Fruit gum, powdered sugar, bread, black peppercorn, habanero overtones, feels heavy, interesting, complex, silky, very approachable.
Finish: Coffee grinds, lingering flavors, smooth, clean, bright, round, soft, creamy, good with a Maduro cigar, rich martini.


Gold Medal
Gold medal


Tahoe Blue Vodka



SILVER MEDAL WINNERS

Meili Vodka
(MT)
Distilled only once from local grains.
Pure ancient aquifer mountain water.

Nose: Powdered cocoa, ripe banana, citrus, tropical, floral, mineral water.
Palate: Cocoa with marshmallow, cocoa, orange cream, citrus, herbal, cereal grains, coffee, potato skin, earthy, mossy, hint of brine, black pepper, cigar box, zesty, creamy.
Finish: Cocoa, powdery, earthy, flavorful, bold, rich, soft, pretty.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Meili Vodka


Howlin’ Hounds Lake Life Vodka
(Missouri Ridge Distillery, MO)
Distilled 100% Missouri grown corn. Limestone filtered water.

Nose: Light lemon, citrus, subtle mint, grassy, mineral, wet stone, toast.
Palate: Vanilla, dough, white bread, rye, grain, slightly nutty, white peppercorn, jalapeño, celery, melon, mineral, stone, wet stone, oak barrel, silky mouthfeel, creamy, soft.
Finish: Volcanic ash water, saline, balanced, flavorful, suitable for sipping & mixing, smooth, delicate.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Howlin’ Hounds Lake Life Vodka


Zakuska Vodka
(KY/OH)
Distilled from soft red winter wheat & corn. Unfiltered.

Nose: Floral, leafy, rye note, subtle pepper, peppery, mineral oil.
Palate: Vanilla, powdered sugar, rye, grassy, wet stone, vermouth, round mouthfeel, creamy, silky, zesty, back to basics.
Finish: Cocoa, very different, intense, clean, crisp, smooth, elegant.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


Zakuska Vodka


IGNITE Vodka
(Ignite Beverage, NY)
4x distilled from corn. Charcoal filtered.

Nose: Anise, grain, rye note, spice, mineral, aerosol, very subtle.
Palate: Vanilla, creamy, nectarine, blood orange, lemon peel, herbal, hint of mint, dough, nutty, white pepper, astringent, icy, intense, very clean, silky mouthfeel.
Finish: Lemon, coffee, dusty, mineral, balanced, complex, intense, bright, nice and easy.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


IGNITE Vodka


White Hills Vodka
(White Hills Distillery, CT)
Distilled from sugar cane.

Nose: Hint of citrus, floral, dry herbs, grain, bread, mineral, clean, fresh.
Palate: Vanilla, vanilla cream, pastry dough, hint of cocoa, almond oil, herbal, lemon, green walnut, jalapeño, white pepper, dusty, round mouthfeel, balanced, clean, soft.
Finish: Toffee, wintergreen, endive, pepper, spice, spring water, clean, smooth, silky, velvety, exceptional.


Silver Medal
Silver medal


White Hills Vodka

 

 


 

Vodka's illustrious history in the Old World is well known. What about American-made vodkas? Whenever a new distillery opens its doors, it’s vodka that they usually produce first, since vodka is made from simple ingredients and doesn’t require a complicated distillation process or barrel aging. There are now over 1,500 brands of unflavored American vodkas – currently produced by micro-distillers all across the country.

Much like craft brewers and vintners, the entrepreneurial master distillers proudly use local grains (or potatoes, corn, grapes, sugarcane, apples, etc.) and local water sources to produce their small batch craft vodkas. These particular ingredients (as well as distillation methods) impart distinctive character and flavors to the finished products. The water sources and the soil from which the base ingredients are grown adds an extra emphasis of "terroir" to the individuality of these artisanal spirits.

 

 

Disclaimer: This section of the website is intended for visitors 21 years of age and older.
If you are not of legal drinking age, please exit by clicking here.


Please drink responsibly!